
How in the Hell do you mess up a pirate movie! It's such an easy equation to stick to: have a simple, direct plot, have enjoyable characters that make you laugh, and have a buttload of special effects mixed in with music. This is what made
Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl kick so much ass; I don't see why they felt the need to change stuff around.
I think I'm blaming this one on the writers just because the special effects were good and the director seemed to be the same guy. The story did not flow well at all. In the middle of the film you had almost every single major character in cahoots with someone they weren't supposed to be messin' with. To make matters worse, the main characters got split up, so you had random people on different boats and locales, escaping from one and into another, making it very difficult to keep track of things. This is a
Disney movie for Gods sakes, try to simplify a bit. I, as an audience member, became so bamboozled at all of this nonsense that I couldn't help but glance at my watch close to 8 times (that's pretty bad). This film was the longest out of the trilogy and by Jove, did it drag it's slow, not-funny ass across that finish line.
Prior to the last battle,
Keira Knightley sealed the deal for this movie. She started giving this inspirational speech to the pirates about freedom, much like
Mel Gibson would in
Braveheart,
Bill Pullman would in
Independence Day, or
Gerard Butler would in
300. But what do all these films have that this one does not? Legitimacy.
Pirates are usually bad, not good, remember that kids. When you apply that logic to this speech, it'll make your head cock to the side. I actually scoffed in the theater.
The only admirable trait that this film had were crazy special effects. The end of the ship battle was especially memorable, very
Matrix-esque. The music wasn't good because it was the same old melody, just louder, as a fruitless attempt to hide the craptacular story underneath it.
The only reason this movie is making so much money is because it's, hopefully, the last film in this series. It's popularity, by no means, should be a litmus test for it's entertainment value.
Rating - D