So after going back to having a simple phone after the Vibrant fiasco, I could not help but want another touchscreen smartphone. So after browsing around CL and Ebay forever I finally got a captivate through Ebay. The chick on the other end kinda misrepresented the condition of the phone so I managed to get $100 off my bid price which turned out to be less than market. Go me! So yeah after a few months of ownership here is my review of the device.
Hardware-wise the phone is pretty good. The GPS is very flaky so it has been suggested that this is a hardware issue which I believe, but the screen, sound, and overall feel of the phone is still good to go. It doesn't have a front-facing camera so that sucks when compared to the iPhone 4.
Software is where everything falls apart. Android is supposed to be an open platform that is made by Google, so one would think that the programming was OK; it isn't. For one reason or another Google OSes are tweaked with by manufacturers and made more shitty with different keyboards or different front-ends. Why couldn't it just be a Vanilla Google OS? So yeah your options as an android user are to use an antiquated ROM that is never updated or to try to root your phone and use a multitude of different ROMs that Joe Nobody in some random basement coded from a leaked ROM. The official stock ROM sucks and custom ROMs are hit or miss depending on if the developer is smart or not. It's just so frustrating to have only these two options at hand.
In comparison, the Apple iOS is pretty stable and updates come regularly. This is one thing that Apple has over Android and it's beginning to be more important. At the end of the day the device is a cell phone and there are certain expectations that need to be met:
- Simple
- Works
- Bugs are fixed
Currently Android has none of these expectations met.
So what is annoying about this phone/OS? A lot. First off the updates are few and far between. There have been many on-line arguments about if it is
Google's fault or
Samsung's. Most have said that it is
Samsung's. It's very lame that the cell phone community has to depend on
XDA programmers to tweak with leaked
ROMs in order to get them to work on various cell phones. I don't see why
Samsung does not invest some of their resources to do what they are supposed to do. The reasoning posed has been because of money and the fact that it is not in their best interest to support new OS versions like
Froyo and Gingerbread on older phones. People will eventually just buy new phones with newer native OSes already installed. Pretty fucked up if you ask me. Why does the OS even need to be configured? Isn't it really just a small computer?
Anyway, what else...yeah the "system sound" settings will reset 80% of time time after you power off the phone meaning that whenever it boots back up it'll play this annoying Galaxy S tune at full blast. Another thing is that menu clicks will either lag or not detect so you are forced to click a bunch of more times. The
Youtube app will also not sync up with your real account meaning that if I
login on both the computer and the phone, and if I watched one a video from a subscription, the computer or phone will not know that the video has already been watched.
WTF. Isn't this was logging in is all about? The phone also crashes apps quite often and occasionally the whole OS will crash and you'll have to take the battery out. So in comparison Android phones are very much like a PC whereas the
iPhones are very similar to Apple's
OSs. Yeah does it mean it is better? Yes, in many places concerning stability, but not everywhere. For example Android phone apps are almost always free and they are very functional as a free program whereas Apple apps are not so. But
iPhones are a lot more stable and they "just work".
For cases I was cheap and tried to buy a $2 hard case off of Ebay from HK. It turned out that the case was only good the first time you put in on. Subsequent times that you put it on then off, it would be harder to get it to snap back into place. After a few times it just wouldn't snap anymore and that was it. I also found out later that the case itself scratched up the phone in 3 locations on the actual plastic so yeah... bullocks to that. I then ordered some cheapo-silicone case from HK and that one has been doing better than the hard case. The most annoying part is that the rubber totally sticks to your pockets so it's harder to get in and out. Next I'll try some "TPU" material although I don't really know what it is...maybe it's just another fancy word for rubber.
So in conclusion I hate Apple as much as any PC person does but I do feel torn when it comes to cell phones. A phone is supposed to work...all the time. When I'm able to officially upgrade phones in March it'll be a hard decision of what to do. The Nexus S recently got released but of course it does not support AT&T's 3G frequency; so yeah, even though it has Gingerbread and a front-facing camera, what's the use if the speed is piss poor? Will the iPhone 4 be the only AT&T option at that time? I hope not, but yeah that thing just works even though it is a crappy Apple product.